Tradition 5
Short form
Each group has but one primary purpose — to carry the message to the alcoholic who still suffers.
Long form
Each Alcoholics Anonymous group ought to be a spiritual entity having but one primary purpose— that of carrying its message to the alcoholic who still suffers.
Excerpt from the Twelve Steps & Twelve Traditions
“Shoemaker, stick to thy last!”... better do one thing supremely well than many badly. That is the central theme of this Tradition. Around it our Society gathers in unity. The very life of our Fellowship requires the preservation of this principle.
Alcoholics Anonymous can be likened to a group of physicians who might find a cure for cancer, and upon whose concerted work would depend the answer for sufferers of this disease. True, each physician in such a group might have his own specialty. Every doctor concerned would at times wish he could devote himself to his chosen field rather than work only with the group. But once these men had hit upon a cure, once it became apparent that only by their united effort could this be accomplished, then all of them would feel bound to devote themselves solely to the relief of cancer. In the radiance of such a miraculous discovery, any doctor would set his other ambitions aside, at whatever personal cost.
Just as firmly bound by obligation are the members of Alcoholics Anonymous, who have demonstrated that they can help problem drinkers as others seldom can. The unique ability of each A.A. to identify himself with, and bring recovery to, the newcomer in no way depends upon his learning, eloquence, or on any special individual skills. The only thing that matters is that he is an alcoholic who has found a key to sobriety. These legacies of suffering and of recovery are easily passed among alcoholics, one to the other. This is our gift from God, and its bestowal upon others like us is the one aim that today animates A.A.'s all around the globe.
There is another reason for this singleness of purpose. It is the great paradox of A.A. that we know we can seldom keep the precious gift of sobriety unless we give it away. If a group of doctors possessed a cancer cure, they might be conscience-stricken if they failed their mission through self-seeking. Yet such a failure wouldn't jeopardize their personal survival. For us, if we neglect those who are still sick, there is unremitting danger to our own lives and sanity. Under these compulsions of self-preservation, duty, and love, it is not strange that our Society has concluded that it has but one high mission— to carry the A.A. message to those who don't know there's a way out.
Highlighting the wisdom of A.A.'s single purpose, a member tells this story:
“Restless one day, I felt I'd better do some Twelfth Step work. Maybe I should take out some insurance against a slip. But first I'd have to find a drunk to work on.
“So I hopped the subway to Towns Hospital, where I asked Dr. Silkworth if he had a prospect. 'Nothing too promising,' the little doc said. 'There's just one chap on the third floor who might be a possibility. But he's an awfully tough Irishman. I never saw a man so obstinate. He shouts that if his partner would treat him better, and his wife would leave him alone, he'd soon solve his alcohol problem. He's had a bad case of D.T.'s, he's pretty foggy, and he's very suspicious of everybody. Doesn't sound too good, does it? But working with him may do something for you, so why don't you have a go at it?'
“I was soon sitting beside a big hulk of a man. Decidedly unfriendly, he stared at me out of eyes which were slits in his red and swollen face. I had to agree with the doctor— he certainly didn't look good. But I told him my own story. I explained what a wonderful Fellowship we had, how well we understood each other. I bore down hard on the hopelessness of the drunk's dilemma. I insisted that few drunks could ever get well on their own steam, but that in our groups we could do together what we could not do separately. He interrupted to scoff at this and asserted he'd fix his wife, his partner, and his alcoholism by himself. Sarcastically he asked, 'How much does your scheme cost?'
“I was thankful I could tell him, 'Nothing at all.'
“His next question: 'What are you getting out of it?'
“Of course, my answer was 'My own sobriety and a mighty happy life.'
“Still dubious, he demanded, 'Do you really mean the only reason you are here is to try and help me and to help yourself?'
“'Yes,' I said. 'That's absolutely all there is to it. There's no angle.'
“Then, hesitantly, I ventured to talk about the spiritual side of our program. What a freeze that drunk gave me! I'd no sooner got the word 'spiritual' out of my mouth than he pounced. 'Oh!' he said. 'Now I get it! You're proselytizing for some damn religious sect or other. Where do you get that “no angle” stuff? I belong to a great church that means everything to me. You've got a nerve to come in here talking religion!'
“Thank heaven I came up with the right answer for that one. It was based foursquare on the single purpose of A.A. 'You have faith,' I said. 'Perhaps far deeper faith than mine. No doubt you're better taught in religious matters than I. So I can't tell you anything about religion. I don't even want to try. I'll bet, too, that you could give me a letter-perfect definition of humility. But from what you've told me about yourself and your problems and how you propose to lick them, I think I know what's wrong.'
“'Okay,' he said. 'Give me the business.'
“'Well,' said I, 'I think you're just a conceited Irishman who thinks he can run the whole show.'
“This really rocked him. But as he calmed down, he began to listen while I tried to show him that humility was the main key to sobriety. Finally, he saw that I wasn't attempting to change his religious views, that I wanted him to find the grace in his own religion that would aid his recovery. From there on we got along fine.
“Now,” concludes the oldtimer, “suppose I'd been obliged to talk to this man on religious grounds? Suppose my answer had to be that A.A. needed a lot of money; that A.A. went in for education, hospitals, and rehabilitation? Suppose I'd suggested that I'd take a hand in his domestic and business affairs? Where would we have wound up? No place, of course.”
Years later, this tough Irish customer liked to say, “My sponsor sold me one idea, and that was sobriety. At the time, I couldn't have bought anything else.”
Excerpt from The Twelve Traditions Illustrated
Please click the link below to open the pamphlet The Twelve Traditions Illustrated and read Tradition Five or read the image below.
Every newcomer learns (some of us the hard way) that the business of staying sober must have top priority. If we fail at that, we can't succeed at anything else. The Fifth Tradition tells us that groups should remember their "one primary purpose."
Often unthinking enthusiasm puts a group off the main track. One, for instance, offered an "expanded AA program" that included helping newcomers to find jobs. Tradition Five doesn't frown on the individual AA who tells another about a good opening. But when the group turns itself into an employment agency, newcomers may get confused about their primary purpose. AA's function is to help them get sober–then they can find work for themselves.
Using discretion, a member may lend a few dollars needed for a meal or a hotel room, or may even invite a broke alcoholic to be a temporary houseguest. But the AA group as a whole is not a friendly finance company, not a welfare department, not a housing bureau.
Even when acting on their own, as individual members, AA lay people certainly shouldn't award themselves honorary medical degrees and hand out diagnosis and prescriptions and amateur analysis of other people's neuroses. Exactly because this personal failing is so common, the AA group in all its dealings should be extra careful to emphasize that it is not invading the medical field. Through the personal experiences of its members, it is qualified to carry only one message: how an alcoholic can recover in AA. That's all.
Yet one group felt itself equipped to set up an "alcoholism information centre." The temptation in understandable; it was even stronger at the time this Tradition was written, because public ignorance about alcoholism an an illness was more widespread that it is now. Since then, other agencies have sprung up to assume the task of educating the general public on alcoholism. That is not AA's purpose, but these agencies also are trying to help the active alcoholic. They are our friends–and Tradition Six marks the boundaries of the relationship...
Tradition Five Discussion Questions
Am I willing to explain firmly to a newcomer the limitations of AA help, even if he gets mad at me for not giving him a loan?
Am I willing to twelfth-step the next newcomer without regard to who or what is in it for me?
Does our group carry the message effectively? Could we do anything to make it clearer?
Do I know exactly what the message is?
Do I help my group in every way I can to fulfil our primary purpose?
Do I remember that AA old-timers, too, can be alcoholics who still suffer? Do I try both to help them and to learn from them?
Do I understand how a group is defined?
Thoughts on Tradition Five
Firstly, perhaps it is worth spending some time considering what an AA group actually is. Groups are more fluid and less clearly defined that they are in our literature. In the UK, most groups hold only one meeting. In some places in the UK and across the world groups hold several meetings, sometimes in one place, often in many. These multi-meeting groups help to reduce the need for so many service positions and help to build unity in one place. What is the difference between a meeting and a group then? Meetings are one activity that a group undertake. A true group operates not only within their meeting(s) but outside of the meeting time(s) also. They may undertake workshops, social events and organise twelfth step work. So a group as defined in our literature is more than just a meeting.
Committing to a home group in most groups in the UK is therefore more restricting that it might be in a town in the United States, but it is still an important choice. Experience shows that there are significant benefits and responsibilities to committing to one group as a home group. The home group is where service begins. It is where we can commit to attend and where newer members are nurtured and supported. Service in the home group does not require a title and having a group of people committed to one group means that service bed hoppers (where members hop from group to group finding service and are not really committing to a group) are not needed. Having a regular core of members allows for properly considered group conscience meetings to take place where members can have their say with a sound knowledge of the group and its' history. A home group is also the place where we cast our vote and view our opinions on matters affecting AA as a whole. After all, voting on a matter such as conference questions in multiple groups would not be democratic. One person, one vote is the foundation of democracy.
Much discussion has been had over the years regarding the difference between 'the message' and 'its' message'. The fact that these words seem interchangeable between the long and short version of the tradition doesn't help. Whichever we prefer, it's clear that carrying the message of AA ought to be the fundamental purpose of the group. But this implies that other purposes may be considered. Tradition Six gives us the guidance on this.
So what is the message of AA? It's not something that is commonly summarised. Consider the suggestion below. You may be able to summarise it better yourself.
'We believe that we suffer from an abnormal physical reaction to alcohol which means that we cannot drink normally and a mental obsession that means we cannot keep from drinking. The only long term solution we have found for sobriety is the spiritual programme as laid out in the Twelve Steps.'
As the primary purpose of a group is to carry the message, perhaps it's worth considering whether or not our sharing reflects that enough. As time has passed and an increasing number of us come to AA via recovery services sharing has become more akin to group therapy. While there is certainly a lot of similarities, there is a key difference. Group therapy is focussed on sharing for the benefit of the sharer while sharing of the message puts the focus on those listening. While it would be entirely wrong to require members to carry the message (or parts thereof) every time they share, we can each take responsibility for our own sharing and lead by example. As the old AA axiom goes; "carry the mess to your sponsor and the message to the meeting." Guidance I have found useful to to ask myself where the 'but' is. I can share my difficulties in a meeting but I can add how the programme is helping me and by doing so carry the message.
This tradition also makes clear who we can help. As alcoholics with experience of alcoholism we are uniquely equipped to help other alcoholics. In modern times there is a trend in the recovery services to lump all addictions together. While it is clear that there are similarities, it is our direct experience that sets us apart.
So how do people find us so that we can carry the message. While anonymity is a subject that we will cover later on in the traditions, it is worth mentioning here. If we are entirely anonymous we lose the chances that might arise if we are known to friends and family as recovered alcoholics. Tradition Eleven makes clear the exact level we ought to be anonymous at — the public level. This, however, is a personal choice, but Dr. Bob was quite emphatic about this.
Warren recalled, “He (Dr. Bob) said there were two ways to break the anonymity Tradition: (1) by giving your name at the public level of press or radio; (2) by being so anonymous that you can’t be reached by other drunks.”
Dr. Bob and the Good Oldtimers, p. 264